Topics in this domain

Risk Management Process

Risk · 3 min read

What risk actually is

“Risk” gets used loosely. In risk management it has a precise shape: something valuable (an asset), something that could harm it (a threat), and a weakness that would let the harm happen (a vulnerability).

Threat exploits a vulnerability to harm an asset, causing impact.

Think of your home. The asset is your laptop. The threat is a burglar. The vulnerability is an open window. The impact is losing the laptop and everything on it. Close the window (fix the vulnerability) or move to a safer neighbourhood (reduce the threat) and the risk drops.

A threat with no vulnerability to use, or a vulnerability no threat can reach, poses little risk. Controls work by reducing the likelihood (closing gaps, blocking threats) or reducing the impact (backups, insurance).

  • Inherent risk is the level before any controls.
  • Residual risk is what’s left after controls.

The cycle

Identify assets, threats and weaknesses, analyse, evaluate, treat, monitor and report.
StepWhat happens
1. Set the contextGoals, scope, risk criteria and appetite, stakeholders
2. Identify assetsInformation, systems, processes, people; their value and owners
3. Identify threats and vulnerabilitiesWhat could happen, and what weakness it would exploit
4. AnalyseHow likely, how bad, considering existing controls
5. EvaluateCompare with appetite; prioritise
6. TreatMitigate, transfer, avoid or accept
7. Monitor and reviewTrack risks and controls, watch key risk indicators, reassess after change
ThroughoutCommunicate, and record everything in a risk register

When the exam asks what comes first in a risk assessment, the answer is usually identifying the assets (and their value or criticality). You can’t prioritise threats to things you haven’t listed.

Who does what

  • The board sets risk appetite.
  • Risk owners in the business are accountable for their risks. They decide on treatment and accept the residual risk.
  • The risk function provides the framework and methods, facilitates assessments, and pulls the picture together.
  • Control owners run the controls.
  • Internal audit gives independent assurance that risk management works. It doesn’t own or run it.

This is often called the three lines model: management (first line), risk and compliance (second line), internal audit (third line).

The risk register

A risk register records each risk with its owner, ratings, controls, treatment plan and status:

FieldExample
RiskRansomware encrypts file servers
OwnerCOO
Inherent ratingHigh
ControlsEndpoint protection, offline backups, patching
Residual ratingMedium
Treatment and dateImmutable backups by Q3

Keep it current

Risks change with new systems, threats, suppliers and laws. Assessments should be repeated regularly and after significant change. Key risk indicators give early warning in between.

Example. A company assessed IT risk in January. In June it moved customer data to a cloud service. Without a new assessment, the risk register still talks about on-premises databases and says nothing about the provider, its access model or where the data now lives.

How the exam asks about it

If the question asks…The answer is usually…
The first step in a risk assessmentIdentify and value assets
Who accepts residual risk?The business risk owner (senior management)
What risk is a function ofThreats, vulnerabilities and impact on assets
When to reassess riskRegularly and after significant change
Internal audit’s role in risk managementIndependent assurance over the process

In short

  • Risk management starts with context and assets, then threats and vulnerabilities, then analysing likelihood and impact.
  • Risk exists when a threat can exploit a vulnerability to harm an asset.
  • Risk evaluation compares each risk with the organisation's appetite to decide what to do.
  • Treatment options are mitigate, transfer, avoid or accept; residual risk must be within appetite and accepted by the risk owner.
  • Risk management is continuous: risks are monitored and reassessed, especially after changes.
  • Business risk owners are accountable for their risks; the risk function facilitates; internal audit gives independent assurance.
  • A risk register records each risk, its owner, rating, treatment and status.

Exam traps

  • The first step in a risk assessment is identifying and valuing assets, not picking controls.
  • A vulnerability no threat can exploit (or a threat with nothing to exploit) doesn't create much risk.
  • IT doesn't own business risks. The business owner accepts residual risk.
  • An annual risk assessment isn't enough after a big change; reassess when things change.
  • Audit evaluates the risk management process; it doesn't run it.

Slides

Click the slide and use the arrow keys. F toggles full screen.

CISA · Domain 2 · Risk

Risk Management Process

How organisations find, rank and deal with IT risks, step by step, who owns each part, and the 'what comes first?' questions the exam loves.

1 / 9