Topics in this domain

Alternate Sites: Hot, Warm, Cold

Resilience · 3 min read

Somewhere to go

If your home became unliveable, you could move into a furnished holiday flat and be settled the same day (hot). Or a flat with furniture but no bedding or food (warm). Or an empty flat where you bring everything yourself (cold). The faster option costs more.

Recovery sites work exactly like that.

Mirrored, hot, warm and cold sites from fastest and dearest to slowest and cheapest.
SiteWhat’s thereTypical RTOCost
Mirrored (duplicate)A full duplicate of the primary site with real-time data replication; may share the live loadNear zeroHighest
HotFully configured hardware, software, network and environment; needs current data (restored or replicated)HoursHigh
WarmFacilities, network connections and some equipment; systems must be set up and data restoredDaysModerate
ColdThe basics only: space, power, cooling, cabling. Equipment must be bought and installedWeeksLow
MobileA transportable unit, such as a trailer, delivered to where it’s neededDaysModerate
Reciprocal agreementTwo organisations agree to host each other’s processing in a disasterUncertainLow

Cloud DR is now a common alternative. It behaves like a hot or warm site depending on how much is kept running.

Hot sites, usually commercial, are meant for short-term use, typically weeks, until the primary site or a longer-term alternative is ready. Contracts usually limit how long you can stay.

The trouble with reciprocal agreements

Problems with reciprocal agreements: enforceability, capacity, compatibility, testing, confidentiality and shared disaster.

They’re cheap, but the exam treats them sceptically:

  • hard to enforce legally
  • the partner may have no spare capacity when you need it
  • hardware and software may not be compatible, and drift further apart over time
  • testing is difficult
  • confidentiality concerns
  • if the two organisations are close together, the same disaster can hit both

Read the contract first

Contract terms for capacity, use, assurance and money.

For a commercial recovery site, check:

  • the hardware, software and network configuration to be provided
  • how a disaster is declared, and how quickly the site is available
  • the number of subscribers and the priority rules in a regional disaster (oversubscription risk)
  • the maximum period of use
  • testing rights and frequency
  • physical and logical security at the site
  • the right to audit
  • insurance and liability
  • costs: subscription, declaration fees, daily usage fees

Example. A company relies on a commercial hot site. The auditor reads the contract and finds the provider has 40 subscribers in the same city sharing one recovery floor, allocated first come, first served. In a regional event, the company might get nothing. The auditor recommends reviewing the subscriber ratio and priority terms, or a different strategy.

How the exam asks about it

If the question asks…The answer is usually…
Site that can be operational within hoursHot site
Site with only space and utilitiesCold site
Main concern with a commercial shared siteOversubscription in a regional disaster
Main weakness of reciprocal agreementsNot enforceable; capacity and compatibility issues
Site with near-zero RTO and RPOMirrored / duplicate site
Hot site intended forShort-term use

In short

  • A hot site is fully equipped and can be operational within hours; it's the most expensive conventional option.
  • A warm site has infrastructure and some equipment, but needs systems configured and data restored; recovery in days.
  • A cold site provides space, power, cooling and connectivity only; equipment must be delivered; recovery in weeks.
  • A mirrored (duplicate) site runs in parallel with real-time data, for near-zero RTO and RPO.
  • Mobile sites are transportable units; reciprocal agreements share capacity with another organisation.
  • Commercial site contracts should cover configuration, availability during regional disasters (oversubscription), testing rights, duration of use and audit rights.

Exam traps

  • Hot sites are usually meant for short-term use (weeks), not indefinite operation.
  • Commercial sites shared by many subscribers may be oversubscribed in a regional disaster.
  • Cold sites are cheap but can't meet short RTOs.
  • Reciprocal agreements are rarely enforceable and often break down on capacity and compatibility.
  • The right to test at the site should be in the contract.

Slides

Click the slide and use the arrow keys. F toggles full screen.

CISA · Domain 4 · Resilience

Alternate Sites: Hot, Warm, Cold

The kinds of recovery site, from a full mirror to an empty room, how fast each gets you running, why reciprocal agreements disappoint, and what to check in a recovery site contract.

1 / 8